Tunneling Across a Tiny Gap
“Phonon tunneling” explains heat flow across nanometer-wide gaps, study finds.
Conduction and thermal radiation are two ways in which heat is transferred from one object to another: Conduction is the process by which heat flows between objects in physical contact, such as a pot of tea on a hot stove, while thermal radiation describes heat flow across large distances, such as heat emitted by the sun.
These two fundamental heat-transfer processes explain how energy moves across microscopic and macroscopic distances. But it’s been difficult for researchers to ascertain how heat flows across intermediate gaps.
Now researchers at MIT, the University of Oklahoma, and Rutgers University have developed a model that explains how heat flows between objects separated by gaps of less than a nanometer. The team has developed a unified framework that calculates heat transport at finite gaps, and has shown that heat flow at sub-nanometer distances occurs not via radiation or conduction, but through “phonon tunneling.”
Normally these waves, or phonons, are only able to carry heat within, and not between, materials. However, the new research shows that phonons can reach across a gap as small as a nanometer, “tunneling” from one material to another to enhance heat transport.
The researchers believe that phonon tunneling explains the physical mechanics of energy transport at this scale, which cannot be clearly attributed to either conduction or radiation.
“This is right in the regime where the language of conduction and radiation is blurred,” says Vazrik Chiloyan, an MIT graduate student in mechanical engineering. “We’re trying to come up with a clear picture of what the physics are in this regime. Now we’ve brought information together to demonstrate tunneling is, in fact, what’s going on for the heat-transfer picture.”
Chiloyan and Gang Chen, the Carl Richard Soderberg Professor of Power Engineering and head of MIT’s Department of Mechanical Engineering, publish their results this week in Nature Communications.
Clearing the thermal picture
In the past few decades, researchers have attempted to define heat transport across ever-smaller distances. Several groups, including Chen’s, have experimentally measured heat flow by thermal radiation across gaps as small as tens of nanometers. However, as experiments move to even smaller spacing, researchers have questioned the validity of current theories: Existing models have largely been based on theories for thermal radiation that Chiloyan says “smeared out the atomic detail,” oversimplifying the flow of heat from atom to atom.
In contrast, there exists a theory for heat conduction — known as Green’s functions — that describes heat flow at the atomic level for materials in contact. The theory allows researchers to calculate the frequency of vibrations that can travel across the interface between two materials.
“But with Green’s functions, atom-to-atom interactions tend to drop off after a few neighbors. … You’d artificially predict zero heat transfer after a few atom separations,” Chiloyan says. “To actually predict heat transfer across the gap, you have to include long-range, electromagnetic forces.”
Typically, electromagnetic forces can be described by Maxwell’s equations — a set of four fundamental equations that outline the behavior of electricity and magnetism. To explain heat transfer at the microscopic scale, however, Chiloyan and Chen had to dig up the lesser-known form known as microscopic Maxwell’s equations.
“Most people probably don’t know there exists a microscopic Maxwell’s equation, and we had to go to that level to bridge the atomic picture,” Chen says.
Bridging the gap
The team developed a model of heat transport, based on both Green’s functions and microscopic Maxwell’s equations. The researchers used the model to predict heat flow between two lattices of sodium chloride, or table salt, separated by a nanometer-wide gap.
With the model, Chiloyan and Chen were able to calculate and sum up the electromagnetic fields emitted by individual atoms, based on their positions and forces within each lattice. While atomic vibrations, or phonons, typically cannot transport heat across distances larger than a few atoms, the team found that the atoms’ summed electromagnetic force can create a “bridge” for phonons to cross.
When they modeled heat flow between two sodium chloride lattices, the researchers found that heat flowed from one lattice to the other via phonon tunneling, at gaps of one nanometer and smaller.
At sub-nanometer gaps “is a regime where we lack proper language,” Chen says. “Now we’ve developed a framework to explain this fundamental transition, bridging that gap.”
"In every textbook on heat transfer, undergraduate students learn that there are three different types of heat transfer: convection, conduction, or radiation. This is one of the many well-established laws that are not necessarily valid at the nanoscale," says Jean-Jacques Greffet, a professor of physics at Paris-Sud University who was not involved in the research. "[The group's] finding clarifies our physical understanding of the physical processes [and] sheds new light on the contact-resistance issue between two materials in close contact. This is an issue which is of practical importance for many applications."
This research was funded in part by the U.S. Department of Energy.